19 November 2026
Reform is a Culture, Not a Structure
As Unity Enterprise launch Carers Championing Change, their Chief Executive Fraser Bedwell argues that lasting reform depends on culture change and putting the people who rely on services at the heart of decision making

Scotland is about to undertake the most significant structural reform of its NHS since devolution, alongside proposals to reshape local government. The ambition is welcome, and the case for change is clear. But amid the focus on boards and boundaries, one question risks getting lost: will any of it change the experience of an unpaid carer, or of anyone else who relies on health and social care?
Reform is badly needed, and few would argue otherwise. Yet once again, we’re seeing the debate pulled towards structures: 14 health boards becoming two, and 32 councils potentially becoming between six and ten regional authorities. For this sector, there is perhaps the biggest structural question of all: where social care should sit. These are legitimate questions, and they deserve proper scrutiny. But structures have a way of absorbing the energy of reform, often at the expense of a harder question.
More than 60 years ago, the business historian Alfred Chandler argued that organisations should decide what they want to achieve before deciding how to organise themselves. It sounds obvious, but reform doesn’t always work that way. The risk is that we redraw the system first and fit people’s needs around it afterwards. The First Minister has promised reform that puts the individual at the heart of the changes. That promise will be kept or broken not in the boundaries of a new health board or council, but in how decisions get made within them, and who gets to make them.
As providers, we see both sides of this. Many professionals work hard to involve the people who use services, often under real pressure of time and money. But the system doesn’t always make it easy. Decisions about priorities, policy and practice can end up being made some distance from the people they affect, and what’s learned along the way doesn’t always shape what happens next. Everyone involved can often see what could be better, but rarely has a shared space to act on it.
Carers Championing Change sets out to create that space for unpaid carers. It adapts the Champions Board model that care-experienced young people helped build. Following early success in Ayrshire, it is now being rolled out across Scotland with support from The National Lottery Community Fund. Its starting point is that culture can’t be mandated or restructured into being. It has to be built, in three stages. Carers and professionals think differently, building a real understanding of each other’s realities. They work differently, with carers involved before solutions are fixed. And they decide differently, with carers’ priorities shaping services, budgets and policy.
Our experience in Ayrshire suggests culture shifts when a few principles hold. Relationships come before structures: carers and professionals need time to understand each other before they can decide together. Involvement starts early, while options are still open. And power is shared in practice, not just in principle, whether in setting priorities, shaping practice or deciding how money is spent. In North Ayrshire, carers now choose which local services to fund. In South Ayrshire, they are changing how GP practices identify carers. Some of the biggest improvements have cost nothing. They came from people working differently.
So as the debate about where social care should sit goes on, perhaps it’s worth holding a different question alongside it: not just where decisions are made, but who gets to make them. Decisions shaped by the people who rely on services are more likely to fix the right problems, and to earn the trust any reform needs. Structures can be redrawn in a single parliamentary term. Culture takes longer. That may be exactly why reform should start there.
Carers Championing Change is funded by the National Lottery Community Fund and is a partnership led by Unity Enterprise with the Coalition of Carers in Scotland and Freewheel Coaching.

